1. Business & Finance

Discuss in my forum

Bobbie Sage

Cutting Off Medicaid Health Insurance To Illegal Immigrants-Not the Savings You Would Think

By , About.com GuideApril 17, 2006

Follow me on:

Starting this summer, anyone applying for Medicaid health insurance coverage must show proof of U.S. citizenship. This is due to an effort to save the government money by eliminating illegal immigrants from getting Medicaid health insurance coverage. Sounds like a good savings plan, right?

Unfortunately it may cost health insurance consumers more in the end. Why? Illegal immigrants and people who may have a problem showing U.S. citizenship such as the elderly and homeless are still going to need health care. So, they will still go to health care facilities and the facilities will ultimately be absorbing the costs of all these people who have no health insurance.

Well, do you really think the hospitals and other health care facilities are just going to pay that out of pocket and keep the health care costs the same for paying health insurance consumers? What is likely to happen is that the extra costs will be spread out and absorbed by paying health insurance consumers which adds to the increasing reasons health care costs will likely rise.

Comments
April 25, 2006 at 8:38 pm
(1) Deborah Morris :

I think that all illegal immigrants should be deported.

November 10, 2006 at 4:42 pm
(2) Chris :

I work at a hospital and they do “eat” some of the costs for people who can’t afford their bills. The hospital I work for is required to do so for a certain amount of patients each year. They’re not U.S. citizens. They’re taken our money no matter how you look at it.

April 12, 2007 at 12:37 pm
(3) Elena Jimenez :

Lets, be honest how could health insurance be denied to a human being. everyone has the right to recieve medical care no matter what their legal situation is.
Elena

August 18, 2007 at 10:25 pm
(4) julie bergen :

working in the health care field, it infuriates me illegals get better, even FREE care than i do……..even after paying 1000’s in premiums all my life they have no right to our health care system, they are an infectious drain on it and will continue to leech all they can out of it. stop treating illegals, let them die, go back to their contry, i’m tired of paying for them when i can’t afford my own healthcare costs.

December 4, 2007 at 10:47 pm
(5) Lisa Miller :

I do not think they deserve to get all this free health care when they do not pay taxes. IT’S WRONG NO MATTER HOW YOU LOOK AT IT!!! I do not think they should die though. But I agree that why should they get better health care then people who are legal citizens and pay their taxes.

July 11, 2008 at 8:01 am
(6) reva atkins :

how can you deny anyone health care? illegals don’t pay taxes? trust me they do! how do i know this? i’ve been married to one for 8 years and i pay for his doctor bills and trust me you want to complain about your health coverage? try paying for it all out of your pocket!!!!!!get with the program people insurance companies don’t give a crap about you and how much you pay! you honestly think that if no illegals were here in the u.s. we still wouldn’t be paying high amounts for coverage?????besides who the hell are we to say who belongs in this country? i say if you ain’t cherokee get out!!!!!

August 19, 2008 at 5:17 pm
(7) buyzyrtec :

Our pharmacy and physicians are U.S licensed. You can buy zyrtec and get it as fast as possible! The process of ordering is very simple.

September 5, 2008 at 11:09 pm
(8) Claudia Bueso :

This is a serious problem.. I undertand that many illigal aliens are not the best of the society.. But most of them came to this country to work and to help their families who live in extrem poverty in the rest of the latin american countries.. I dont think that it is fair for a hard worker to lack of healt insurance.. But life is not fair period.
They are humans with rights regardless of their inmigrant status.. As a healt worker(nurse) and a legal inmigrant, I will be an advocated for those that can not speak out for themselves..

September 24, 2008 at 2:31 pm
(9) gayle carvalho :

Julie Bergen, your a moron and your heartless! Let them die? They are human beings.

October 5, 2008 at 10:19 pm
(10) Ellen :

I can’t believe the words of hate I’m reading on this subject. How can people talked about other human beings like they are trash, “let them die” “go back to your own country” God made us all as equals and if someone is sick they do deserve to be treated, these are someone’s daughters, and sons, and mothers and fathers. That’s why the world is becoming such a horrible place to live in, because of insensitive horrible people like some on this forum. If this people cam here it might be for a reason, a lot of this people are just here to work and to give their families back home a better life. We are all blessed with being born in the USA but for some other unfortunate people they have to live in misery, a lot of these illegal women come here escaping from an abusive husband, trying to give their children a better life, so how dare you insensitive people talk like that, “let them die?” Why kind of person would say such a thing. I really feel sorry for you, God forgive you all for writing all this horrible things.

October 11, 2008 at 2:04 am
(11) jreyes :

illegals still get medicaid for their us born children and they also get food stamps and many more benefits. so where is the change they still can get hud housing because of their american children. all the illegals that applied for fema during hurricanes qualified for fema benefits. so the government is not going to stop giving them benefits. an american asking for help during the hurricanes got no food stamp while all illegals were given fema and food stamps and this crap has to stop but it will take all americans to come against the government to change we have to stop giving them automatic citezenship

July 29, 2009 at 10:57 pm
(12) Rick :

In my opinion money has nothing to do with giving illegal immigrants medical care. Backing up a step; I don’t think there should be even one illegal immigrant in this country. Penalties should be so stiff they should be afraid to even think of crossing our border. Concentration Camps maybe? They are tresspassing on private property as I see it. If you feel they are not tresspassing then why even have borders? Just let all the nations of the world open their borders and let everyone run rampant.

All civilized countries have laws on immigration and with good reason. There are rules to become a citizen of this country and they should be followed as designed. If illegal immigrants weren’t illegal then they wouldn’t be called such. Are we to turn a blind eye to the fact they are illegal? Are they more righteous than the bank robber or a the rapist who is still walking the streets unapprehended. I feel every law is to be obeyed or let the law be revoked. As I know it, illegal immigrants are illegals and should be given a 60 day grace period to leave the country or face severe consequences. I don’t believe any person that was born in this country by an illegal immigrant and has not reached the age of 18 should be given citizenship either. I believe in strict adherence to all laws of our land no matter how simple or how complex that law may be!

August 13, 2009 at 12:25 am
(13) Shelley :

OK so we all have our views on this but the facts are, They are illegal because they came here in the dead of night after leaving their Country because they could not get what they needed from there. They knew when they came here that they would not be legal and would not have the same rights as we do yet they made the journey anyway. They come here with a very intitled attitude and expect the American people to take care of them when we have enough people who are citizens who need our help and we struggle to help them. They have babies and expect us to take care of them then if they get caught they say what about our kids how can you split up a family why would you do that to us, WE didn’t THEY did, we insure them educate them and make them part of our country. These people knew what they were doing when they came here and they did it anyway. I for one do not feel sorry for them because there are plenty of immagrents who did it the right way and now THEY have health care. I do not feel it is fair that when you go to the emergancy room and it is filled with people who don’t even speak the languge or have insurance, I have to wait untill they are taken care of when I have insurance and speak the language. I think they should be scared to go to the hospital if they are illegal immigrants because they are BREAKING

August 13, 2009 at 12:27 am
(14) Shelley :

Rick said it best. Thank you Rick when it comes right down to it they are just common criminals.

September 14, 2009 at 10:44 am
(15) lisa :

WOW!!!!!!!!!!!! You people talk like a bunch of losers. America is made from immigrants. Also what kind of person are you to say let them die. Get a life pleaseeeeeee!!!

October 17, 2009 at 1:07 am
(16) caesar :

He he this is unbelievable. You know what I think? The Cherokee people should start kicking out all the “illegal” immigrants and that is including of course anyone that is not a Cherokee and came as a illegal immigrant years and years ago and procreate all these people that do not even know where their real family came from. lol Is this planet Earth. I think you all should watch “Area 51″ some day.

January 11, 2010 at 4:32 pm
(17) USA1 :

(8) Claudia Bueso says:
This is a serious problem.. I undertand that many illigal aliens are not the best of the society.. But most of them came to this country to work and to help their families who live in extrem poverty in the rest of the latin american countries.. I dont think that it is fair for a hard worker to lack of healt insurance.. But life is not fair period.
They are humans with rights regardless of their inmigrant status.. As a healt worker(nurse) and a legal inmigrant, I will be an advocated for those that can not speak out for themselves..

thats fine……..pay for them also…
(15) lisa says:
WOW!!!!!!!!!!!! You people talk like a bunch of losers. America is made from immigrants. Also what kind of person are you to say let them die. Get a life pleaseeeeeee!!!
made up of legal immigrants……once again follow proper procedure and you can become a us citizen…hoppin the fence
and bringing your crime wave with you. is not good.

to everybody who says the deserve this and that. YOU ARE ALL FOOLS!!!. i bet its ok for the illegals to be here as long as its not in your backyard…. you care so much open your door, house them , feed them , and pay all the medical bills.

June 15, 2010 at 10:26 am
(18) clara :

They are lawbreakers when they cross the border, each couple that has come here has at least three to five children so they have to be getting benefits, most americans can’t afford that many. If they cross the border to any other country, they are treated like criminals. Our government has no backbone to stand up to these illegials, it might cost them some votes, Kudo’s to Gov. Jan Brewer, she knows what is going and all should listen to her

July 19, 2010 at 11:56 am
(19) Joshua :

14th amendment to the constitution, look it up people.

July 26, 2010 at 1:09 am
(20) Michael :

Its a pity,that America uses people without documents to its advantage. Its nothing but a modern form of slavery. The people without papers do not sit at home. They Work,using a american’s numbers and keep depositing SS $$ every month. If they stop doing it, the SS Dept will be bankrupt within months,if not weeks. Thats why govt doesnot wish to legalize them.They deposit SS $ knowing they will never get the benefits. Would you do it ? Stop saying send them back, if they go back,nobody is going to do our landscaping and do construction jobs or farm jobs,THATS the truth.

Do they collect unemployment benefits ,Of Course no. Does a regular american know that they are getting extra SS benefits, YES, every year a month before their birthday they get the benefit statement and know that the document shows more income then they earned.

Question : What will happen if we allow then insurance ? They will get coverage,pay premium and use services just like you and me. So why are we not allowing them insurance ? No Life insurance, no medical, no auto ??? Guys ,on one hand we speak of freedom and equality and start wars lasting decades to spread democracy and equality, and then at home have a form of slavery ? Nothing but hypocrisy on our part.No arguments on that

September 2, 2010 at 5:26 pm
(21) Alejandro :

I think people with no legal papers should have benefits. it’s not fair how they have to pay huge amounts of money and not get anything like a license, or credit. and much more. Everyone that was in USA back then was a immigrant, they came from Europe and other parts of the world and they weren’t treated with this behavior. so why now.

August 24, 2011 at 8:12 am
(22) Fawn :

its funny how the obvious illegals feel they should just come over here and live off my hard earned taxed dollar. If they have a child here it should be deported and they shouldnt have any rights whatsoever until they get citizen a social security number learn english and enlist in our military. Wake up people we have a war in our country they are now getting into our legislature.

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.